I got two shades: Fierce & Tangy (matte orange) and Too Cool (a shimmery white).
These are nicely creamy cream shadows that have been likened to MAC Paint Pots, though I haven't found any dupes yet. Hopefully, Maybelline will put out a bunch more colors!
|Fierce & Tangy|
Swatched, the orange wasn't as bright as it was in the pot, but it was still nicely pigmented. I've already thought up a tutorial or two using it. The white was also nicely pigmented, but I think an even application is going to be a bit tricky.
|Fierce & Tangy, Too Cool|
|After being scrubbed with soap and hot water|